posted by
orichalcum at 12:36pm on 03/09/2008
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
My college, as well as many others, had a policy of not reporting or allowing the newspapers to extensively cover student suicides. In part, of course, this was meant to save its reputation; no one wants to send their kids to a place where undergrads are regularly killing themselves. But there was another, and more legitimate reason. Many very depressed, lonely, insecure people who are contemplating suicide very much want attention and affirmation. If a suicide victim is made into a tragic martyr, other vulnerable people may see their act as a success rather than a failure - they got publicity and group mourning and lots of attention.
I'm not criticizing Bristol Palin or her fiance's decision to keep and raise their child. That's their business. But in defense of her mother's candidacy, it appears that the Republican National Convention delegates are cheering her on and celebrating her and her choices. The boy in question will appear with the Palin family on stage tonight, having been flown out by the campaign. She's being held up as a role model for keeping her baby.
Frankly, this worries me - just as the coverage of Jamie Lynn Spears did and to some extent the movie "Juno" - because we should not in any way be glorifying teen pregnancy in this country. Yes, these girls - and I do mean girls - are making difficult choices now that they have been faced with a very hard situation. But it's not a good thing that they're pregnant in the first place! If these girls had been more responsible (one way or another) in the first place, they wouldn't be having to deal with the consequences of abortion, adoption, or becoming a mother while still a teenager themselves.
Figuring out how to treat teen mothers is difficult. I don't like the other traditional extreme of kicking them out on the streets or shutting them up in nunneries, obviously. I don't want public shaming, just a lack of positive coverage. I really worry about the lonely 15-year-old girl with a boyfriend who refuses to wear condoms, who reads about the Palins in People Magazine next week and thinks, "wow, see, everyone loves and supports her for having a kid! And her really cute hockey star boyfriend is going to marry her now, and they'll live happily ever after! Maybe my life would be better if I got pregnant too!"
Because, for most girls, it simply won't. And the RNC delegates and the media are acting extremely irreponsibily and unthoughtfully if they make her into a teen heroine.
I'm not criticizing Bristol Palin or her fiance's decision to keep and raise their child. That's their business. But in defense of her mother's candidacy, it appears that the Republican National Convention delegates are cheering her on and celebrating her and her choices. The boy in question will appear with the Palin family on stage tonight, having been flown out by the campaign. She's being held up as a role model for keeping her baby.
Frankly, this worries me - just as the coverage of Jamie Lynn Spears did and to some extent the movie "Juno" - because we should not in any way be glorifying teen pregnancy in this country. Yes, these girls - and I do mean girls - are making difficult choices now that they have been faced with a very hard situation. But it's not a good thing that they're pregnant in the first place! If these girls had been more responsible (one way or another) in the first place, they wouldn't be having to deal with the consequences of abortion, adoption, or becoming a mother while still a teenager themselves.
Figuring out how to treat teen mothers is difficult. I don't like the other traditional extreme of kicking them out on the streets or shutting them up in nunneries, obviously. I don't want public shaming, just a lack of positive coverage. I really worry about the lonely 15-year-old girl with a boyfriend who refuses to wear condoms, who reads about the Palins in People Magazine next week and thinks, "wow, see, everyone loves and supports her for having a kid! And her really cute hockey star boyfriend is going to marry her now, and they'll live happily ever after! Maybe my life would be better if I got pregnant too!"
Because, for most girls, it simply won't. And the RNC delegates and the media are acting extremely irreponsibily and unthoughtfully if they make her into a teen heroine.
There are 11 comments on this entry. (Reply.)